Anytown, USA (DP). Placebos have a long and well-documented history of bringing hope and healing, enough so that drug companies making serious medical trials work hard to neutralize the effects that would otherwise contaminate their research findings, possibly by a fair margin.
A passionate homemaker explains.
In Lewis Caroll's children's books, we find a clearly articulated principle that words can do more work as long as they're adequately compensated. 'Vaccine' has been cleverly redefined so that it now includes not only inoculation from a weakened or dead bacterial culture, but also an experimental genetic therapy whose long term effects are not only unknown but scarcely even guessed at. And a placebo is the kind of thing that will work almost for free.
A philosopher of science comments further.
When DDT came out, it stopped an epidemic in its tracks, and equally stopped the lingering menace of malaria that was killing more US soldiers in Vietnam than anything else. After these coups, a pesticide that is highly effective at killing insects and is still not known to cause any serious or direct harm to humans was unimpeachable as something which you could not seriously criticize in any public setting.
Peter Kreeft commented that the prophet sees through a glass, darkly, but the archivist sees through a microscope, sharply. In retrospect there was some serious "philosophical noise," a faint societal and philosophical static, that we should have heeded but didn't. Just a few lone naturalists noticed that the frogs in the creeks weren't singing, and then they noticed fish kill, too, but great DDT was not the sort of thing one could fault for a problem. You could not speak ill of DDT!
Here and now we have philosophical noise at the scale of an out-of-control rock concert. It is, as chivalric literature would say, "passing strange" that FEMA so much wants to cook the books that they're actually offering a $9,000 bribe if a death certificate says a COVID death. It is also passing illiberal that Americans who need a heart transplant are taken off the wait list entirely if they refuse to be fully injected. Or that diabetics who decline injections once presented as optional are being deprived of treatment that will prevent purely preventable amputation of their feet. Or employers mandatory vaccine requirement for remote employees who never have and never intend to set foot on an employer's campus. Or
COVID injections: The greatest breakthrough in human health since DDT!
A passerby interjected.
Vaccines are safe, or at least that's what it said on one propaganda sheet meant to quell public hysteria. But why then, not long after being even partially vaccinated, did I have blood clotting that would be fatal if untreated, and why did I have to be put on "the Cadillac of blood thinners" which meant that a bad cut could cause me to bleed to death and left the ER asking of my bleeding what had happened when a four by four inch gauze pad was soaked in less than an hour, with my blood dripping on the floor?
"So," said a grassroots community organizer,
We're beyond rock concert levels of noise. It's a "WTF?" in 15 foot high blinking neon. But there's something else at play. If a word can be redefined after it was taking traction that experimental and untested COVID gene therapy injections simply were not meaningfully vaccines, they decided to redefine "vaccine" to include experimental gene therapy and make "vaccine" and "vax" the word of the year.
The precedent has been set, and now we are redefining "vaccine" at a grass level to the time-tested remedy of a saline placebo: an injection along with the doctor saying "Here is an injection based on a time-tested and powerful principle. Congratulations! You are now fully vaccinated!"
An armchair historian mused:
2022, also callable as 2020 Part Deux, looks like quite a year. We've come a long way since The Medieval Experience: Foundations of Western Cultural Singularity developed cubism, for instance, within a generation. Now we seem to be in a Kali-yuga, and things which would have been astonishing in a generation are happening within a year, on top of a financial crisis that escapes by the year. We've left the comparably merry "decade from Hell" in the dust Islamic ascendency, BLM, new installments of demographics that have to be in a politically correct picture, gay marriage, transgender in the limelight, friends forbidden physical affection such as hugs to try and fight COVID, injections, needing booster shots and being told "not to have a false sense of security" just because you're fully vaccinated—we've left cubism in the dust. And in six months to a year, maybe less, people may be able to date my words closely by key new features of the future landscape cannot now even hint at. (Is the Antichrist out yet? Or are we just working on a Matrixy realization that we are "already in the Metaverse?")
Today is kind of like you're a little kid and you've been engaged in playing outside in the snow and your parents make you come in, and it stings and you don't want to come in however much you want. You don't realize how frozen and numb you are until you are shocked by the pain.
And all this without a discussion of whether Romans 1 applies today.
A skeptic in the crowd asked, "Do you think a simple change in words will help?" And a monastic aspirant answered:
The people in power certainly expect as much, and it bothered them that they were losing a debate about whether COVID injections really were in fact vaccines at all. But come, let us dig deeper.
Someone I know wrote The Consolation of Theology does include A Hymn to Arrogance, and it is well worth reading.
And perhaps there are greater concerns than who assigns the definition of "vaccine."